Ethernet/IP vs. PROFINET: A Comprehensive Comparison for Industrial Networks-amikonpower.com

Ethernet/IP vs. PROFINET: A Comprehensive Comparison for Industrial Networks

December 04,2024

Ethernet/IP vs. PROFINET: A Comprehensive Comparison for Industrial Networks

Introduction: Understanding the Rise of Industrial Ethernet

Ethernet has revolutionized the industrial landscape, offering control engineers more autonomy, flexibility, and control over processes. With Ethernet's ability to seamlessly facilitate communication between industrial devices, production processes can be optimized, operational costs reduced, and data-driven insights harnessed for smarter decision-making. Among the most widely used Ethernet-based protocols are Ethernet/IP and PROFINET, both of which play critical roles in industrial automation networks. In this article, we'll explore the key differences between these two protocols, highlighting their unique features, benefits, and use cases.

(Matrox 15068 847954393 14695 DT3153/TB233-250-15-E2A4P4-N 09.03. 250A/B+B E28134426921 LPS-1.0 Z5542998-P01 344 26922 03/TB233-250-13-E2A4P4 UHL2/P50B05020DXV00 BL/RSW-H-100 RC RSWH100/KV-LM20V PLC KV-8000/SNMP-IPC-EXT2 . B101-1 19A6100021 9692010012E/B-EVA-E EVA-E)

What is Ethernet/IP? An Overview

Ethernet/IP (Ethernet Industrial Protocol) is an industrial networking protocol that integrates Ethernet with the Common Industrial Protocol (CIP). It was developed in the late 1990s and has since become one of the most popular protocols for Ethernet-based communication in industrial automation. Ethernet/IP operates at the application layer of the OSI model, providing an efficient method for controlling devices and systems using Ethernet as the underlying communication medium.

(CJ1W-ETN21/enteliZONE eZ-440R4-230 eZ440R4230/SEC-Z719JX Z700 Type 000013 Gas SiCl4 125SCCM/Z700 SEC-Z712MGX 797-154719-007 10SLM Gas N2/MCH-3010D/HYPFU-420TS2/MUMA022P1S/SS-8BK-1C 3E1 50 BOU 24VDC/UCV SUSF316L IILE/iSMA-B-FCU-HH/KIPS PS70-3 101001300 A5 PS70-TI/KCI PS70-3 101001300 A6 PS70-TI/FC-30 EASYIO30P HVAC&R BMS)

Ethernet/IP supports a wide range of devices and facilitates communication between control systems and input/output (I/O) devices. Some of the key benefits of Ethernet/IP include its flexibility in installation, compatibility with standard internet protocols, and the variety of equipment and suppliers available, making it a versatile choice for many industrial applications.

(O3-DIN-PWRINJ R1.4 O3-DIN/Ion Power 8300/ASG HVAC BMS/51-2235-00 22-2235-01/PH8906 004 ME03-96-64P-M4LT1-A1/KNIEL FDC 5.12/24/PFS A 900-055-02 .01 07.91481-9058/KZ-50 90~250VAC 12VDC KZ50/HP M1072-66531 B3448-01347 M1072-B5002/ACM112S-0.4 AC ACM100 213-09407 PV324/7252-046.0002 PC EAU-2/2211 A-8215A)

What is PROFINET? Key Insights
PROFINET (Process Field Network) is an industrial Ethernet protocol that enables high-speed, real-time communication between automation devices such as controllers (PLCs) and field devices (e.g., I/O modules, sensors, and actuators). Launched in the early 2000s, PROFINET has rapidly become one of the leading protocols in industrial automation due to its high-speed data transmission and versatility in handling a wide range of applications.

(DPD1T-A80 160 Psi 11.0Bar DPD1TA80/MS-IOM2721-0 IOM2721/7-2OHGMA140GRID 7.2 KV AMPS140/1002745/NEC-16T PC-9801-92 G8NVA 06 NEC PC-9800/434900 00/32 N.003/TMS-4 ASYNC CARD #9012 TMS-X 9104-A R/PIOC POWER-48.2/E ATOS 93-09-169.01PMM-BA-5603-1 /PMMBA56031/1127406C1/F940GOT-SWD V4.00 HMI SER GOT-F900)

Developed by PROFIBUS & PROFINET International (PI), PROFINET ensures robust interoperability between various devices and adheres to international standards like IEEE 802 and IEC 61158. Its ability to support both real-time and non-real-time communication has made it especially popular in high-demand, time-sensitive environments, such as motion control and precision manufacturing.

(734821C1/FGA-0272A FTC-DIN-GT-HT-ST-AM4/O1D100 01DLF3KG/Sony XC-37 CCD/DIRIS A20 48250200 RS485 48250082/00351603-01. 00351603S01 ST/phoenix contact Kongsberg MR-17/EM-M11A/SGMPH-02AAA21/AS E9740KA-0 PC 25L01W1 E9740KP-02/MCP-V MCP OCP 2503B-4/Man Roland BP.UC-1 16.85400-3045)

Ethernet/IP vs. PROFINET: A Comparison
While both Ethernet/IP and PROFINET share common ground as Ethernet-based industrial protocols, they differ significantly in their focus and functionalities. Here are some key differences to consider when choosing between the two:

Feature	Ethernet/IP	PROFINET
Real-Time Communication	Standard Ethernet with limited real-time features	Ultra-fast real-time communication (1碌s)
Safety Features	CIP Safety integration	PROFIsafe integration
Network Topology	Ring, star, linear, hybrid	Ring, star, line, and more complex topologies
Installation Flexibility	Copper, fiber optics, wireless connectivity	Copper, fiber optics, wireless solutions
Compatibility	Compatible with major internet protocols like HTTP, FTP, and SNMP	Highly standardized and widely used in manufacturing automation systems

(64-236054-00-B IS-33 61-150023/IMS IM483I-SC1 V1.15i DR0116 W/ APSS-1/1055-01-10-20-32 SW. 3.16 W/ 400/11/UMG 96-S2 5234002 UMG96S2/PBP-14P4 R1 M1 14- 160216-14164 SRC500/403199-004. 3026.2-005 B 403204-304/KAA100/LDS2C-D LIMO/644HANAXAJ6Q4/AMP 300 3381-000111-14 3381-000113-1/PDS13-2/Omega Newport 6155AS/M802-MD4/CJ1W-AD081-V1 A/D/UFC-8565 Gas N2(SC 13) 100SCCM/MR-J2S-40A-PA008)

Choosing Between Ethernet/IP and PROFINET
When deciding between Ethernet/IP and PROFINET, the right choice depends largely on your specific industrial application. If real-time performance and precision control are paramount—such as in motion control or robotics—then PROFINET might be the better option due to its faster communication speeds and integrated safety features.

(FY6PF10N-303 6H9FBN-1/A4125A HP c240 A4125-66512/2000 SEPAM2000 SEPAM 2025/LXM32MU60N4/CMV-C202GQ11 MFG NO. 3038 CMVC202GQ11/TRK2000 GSM GPS/YK02-00200 T709-503 05J25/JX6-I16 . V0.00 d-I160 JX6i16/DVI-D KVM CRV-SLDFMT2SL/Elscint CT Scan / MRI/5610120130 04W52 / GRFY045f20E24/Amelec ADC271X)

On the other hand, if your focus is on flexibility, compatibility with IoT platforms, and a wide range of equipment and suppliers, Ethernet/IP could be the ideal choice. Its integration with internet protocols and widespread industry adoption makes it a reliable option for applications that require a diverse set of devices.

Conclusion
Both Ethernet/IP and PROFINET offer significant advantages in industrial networks, each with its strengths and specialized features. Ethernet/IP is ideal for applications requiring flexibility, scalability, and integration with IoT platforms, while PROFINET excels in high-speed, real-time environments with critical safety requirements.

(ACS-Controls System GWA-250/ICP AT Power Supply ACE-716A/AU-321/SX65-mA SX-65-T-ANA SX-65/110071001/PCEF 2 EAE 597071 0516.PCEF 2 597071/OEMPCX20/5-485X CCSI PCX20 ISA PC/H22NRHT-LNF-NS-02/3564 K 024 B K1194/CLMD 13 20.030.81602/DL1540CL 701540/413F-04-3 199.99/CLG-10D4102 Oil/EAN15A-304 UE/S5 6ES5-441-8MA11 E- 6ES54418MA11/CJ1W-SCU21-J4 -J4/6333B 2- 6333B)

Ultimately, the choice between these two protocols should be based on the specific needs of your industrial network, considering factors like real-time requirements, safety standards, and network topology. Whether you choose Ethernet/IP or PROFINET, both offer robust, reliable solutions for modern industrial automation.

Amikon sells new and surplus products and develops channels to purchase such products.

This site is not approved or endorsed by any of the listed manufacturers or trademarks.

Amikon is not an authorized distributor, dealer or representative of the products displayed on this site.

All product names, trademarks, brands and logos used on this site are the property of their respective owners.

The description, illustration or sale of products under these names, trademarks, brands and logos is for identification purposes only and is not intended to indicate any affiliation with or authorization by any rights holder.

sales7@amikon.cn 86-18965423501 86-18965423501 AMKPLC

DBG60B-01	ET200S, 6ES7138-4AA00-0AA0	MS-IOM2721-0 . 5.1.4 IOM IOM2721	LCS-8630. C1 AN-520BT . G3 ISA
6ED1052-1MD00-0BA6	6AV6574-1AF04-4AA0	MS-IOM2721-0 . C . 5.1.4 IOM IOM2721	PIA-680 A2 V.01
COM/1/2/H - COM-AD-000	SKH D32 GSE 5/16 RH2	V600-CA5D02 ID 24VDC	371X 77-39247582 LEF/API
6ED1055-1MM00-0BA1	RIM16S-8A, RIM8S-16A	SE 11200037 se1m SW 02.00.01 SE11200037se1m	EVF 8203-E 00450487 33.8203-E.28.11
6ES5375-0LC21	PG/OP396 TO PT 8./DR2, 6ES5735-1BD20	SH5S-D Hi	CLMD13 . 20.030.81533 3/15kV
6ES7138-4AA01-0AA0	GDF-22-350-A1A1-350N	03055431S01 / CPP SMT	PIC8S P001-A-000340 MVC-PIC 8-4-00 PCI
1006422 - WL9-P030S01	6GT2090-0VA00-0AX0	03058627-06 c+p20a SMT 03058627s06 FAU-N3-54510	SG BR 400-100 BR 400-100...400 01001.00139
3UF7300-1AU00-0	SWK-1340	03008287S01	0190-16926 DNPCPCI3U1-NC-3V V1.3.4
ABL8RPS24030	AWA01, AW A01, AWAS-1.0	950-596-03. TW596	CKD EV2509-0080E2
ABL8REM24030	ZB4BS547	SMC X114 VJ324M VJ314R VJ314	SP701.0007
PT-100 4800040, ISOV/I100	E132659, E82ZZ75134B210	VAT 221692 WD0951500801232L 221 689B	SST-3000-829
MCR-C-I/I-40-DC	6ES5431-8MD11	HD67590-232-A1	CLG-10D4235 10D4235
6ES5300-5CA11	6ES7221-1BF20-0XA0	PT 2xEX(I) 24DC-ST 2838225 2838225100	EZ-Zone RMEA-KAKA-AAAA RM
3RT1024-1BB44	RF170C, 6GT2002-1HD00	Matrox Iris GT300	3700-01824
6ES5420-4UA12	LCP101, 130B1124	1956703-503 H 1956702-401B	CMV-C302gQ2
774150	6AV2124-0GC01-0AX0	FX0-20MR JY550D19501B	1756-OW16I 1756-OW16IA FW 3.2
G110 - 6SL3255-0AA00-4BA1	6ES5373-0AA81	15-462-11Q / 1546211	FEW-K4A5vb
6SL3260-4MA00-1VB0	6FC5211-0AA00-0AA0	MTR B-50365 Tech # 70487-10	1017862 841-01661
STBDDO3600	LC1D188	H8007405043 BC-SEE10-D	JNTHBCBA0001-BE-U JNTHBCBA0001BEU
IM151-1 STANDARD - 6ES7151-1AA02-0AB0	3RV1021-0HA15	H8010352137 BC-SEE10-D	Shihlin Electric A1-20MR
43170051 - CCA 30/5	II5300	XXS NO2 P/N 6810884 (NO2) Sn.ARNA-0466	966-360-000 T-1001
43170002 - CCA31	DM16, 6ED1055-1CB10-0BA0	R RS1A01AAW AC RS1A01AA	ESS402 ESS-402
A1S61PN	6ES7193-7CA00-0AA0	MACS I/O PCB PB317568-2536-1	CEL-5/60
43170009 - CCA37	SAL350, 2046449	HNWG50086423-005 . PWA 50087799	840-07187 P5 PXEL TEC # 71135 B-52123 RVSI
SHR-7 K1	SAL700, 2046451	452210820682 . 452210526685	DPD1T-A80 DPD1TA80
XBTZ9780	6SL3162-2MA00-0AA0	SP8883-2766 SC827041E-24VDC	KNIEL FDC 5.12/24/PFS 900-055-02 .02 07.91481-9058
6ES7241-1CH30-1XB0	6ES5445-3AA11	SMAR DF53	Kniel C 5.5 101-013-02.03 801035.3475
6ES7151-1BA00-0AB0	6214-2RS1	AMAT 0041-27435 0010-44950	MEISEI 100D CPU PW-12811E MK-100D
175Z0401	R1036X40XX	KLA-Tencor PCB986/0/0 14 ISA	MEISEI PW-12813E MK-100D 8COT
156104 - ORR 2NA 100 I2	6DS9207-8AA	VHR-11-5-20 DC 20A VHR11520	P6 Interface Board 1.0
ET200S - 6ES7131-4BF00-0AA0	CT-SF22-C3 4800103.003	C60K-CDR-A 60VA C60KCDRA	ASTEX PC10015 Rev-A SA7651Relay 18741
PNP - FS-N11P	GA GFIV1.0 DTEC-GFI	FBLD40A 1.0A 115V AC	DEC KJ023500
3RT1015-1AP04-3MA0	A1NCPU PLC CPU A1N-CPU	PI-98 P/N 22-376102-00 50000SCCM GAS N2/ AR FW. 3.02	PVME PCI-VME
LAD7B106	Plum-001 P-900155	840-07188 PYM TEC# 71138 B52126 RVSI	HC-SFS201 HCSFS201
6GK5005-0BA00-1AB2	SGDM-01ADA 50332 R10288-907-88	900SB/ RS232-880	03-70FT-100-355 0370FT100355
OJ5065	TSX3721101 PLC TSX TSX 3721	MCH51AB1174 MCH 12V DC	7206862-1
CQM1-PA203	B25A20FACR-INV	PF9901 PF9901-V1 300V 20A	7222045
6ES5705-0AF00	PW404 S1 PW404 AS S982LAT-07	0010-B7970	TEC ASM 73406 PCLM TEC 73405
222-1BH00	A52844530 IM	OMRON R88M.KE10030H-S2	SYSMAC-C C120-PRO15 3G2A6-PRO15 W/ C20-CN122
7MF4997-1AM	QTERM-J10 Model. J244	TC420 TC-420	PCFI075TL-B
6ES5755-4AA11	SA EF-SP/05 4610 EFSP05	996-0301-01LF B EL240.128.45 LCD	C40061-04D
6ES5735-2CB00	PMA KS 50 9404 407 82001 8414 PMA	R7D-ZP02H SMARTSTEP 03202	PVME PCI-VME SFPCI-VME
IF963-X27, 6ES7963-3AA00-0AA0	AP4580h 3PWD FV4 FV4 FV4 PF H1	RC02-KSG RC02KSG	HC-SFS201
ET200PRO - 6ES7142-4BD00-0AB0	ASM 00351602-01 00351602S01	41-09-629273	000-3008622 0003008622
W-784/W744-1 - 6GK5798-8MJ00-0AA0	V-TIO-B FK02-VV*1NN-NN-P-5 CT	TJ20 MAN. 6627095FI	6FM 1590-5AA00 6FM15905AA00
8POINT	ASM 02-82797/AP ASM 03-20860-01/BQ	DAQ-R320-L3	SS-BNV51-C 1/4 316L W/ 3E1 50
6ES7223-3BD30-0XB0	P50B05010DCNSC AC BL P5	DAQ-R32I-L3-Rev00-00	6LV-BNN33-C B3E1
6ES5958-4UA11	12A8M PWM APDP01	PWA 83657-01 G . PWB83659-01 B	L6281-331 NW 16 A/O 24V W/ PS1-E 24
N-ID8	12A8 APDP01	110CPU31100 CPU 043506689 01.04 AEG	459800248231 452-31 iCT 4598-002-46051 cm71
FTL370	BLB-020972 . PLB-4209728822 M6541AD	4506n9922E200	NW25 A/O 24V L6281332 W/ 341142 PSI-E 24

Hot tags : UNI1402 FS-SCCNTL03 330850-90-00

blogs